Historical Horse Racing

The Best American Turf Horses

of the Twentieth Century

By: Walter Lazary /// Rev'd. Sept. 2022 /// Comments Box at end.

The Emergence of Turf Racing in America

In the first half of the twentieth century, turf racing in North America was virtually unheard of even though many horses bred here during that time were sired by stallions imported from England and France, such turf specialists as Nasrullah, Princequillo, Bull Dog, Sir Gallahad, Blenheim II, and Mahmoud, etc.

In 1950, the Daily Racing Form Manual recognized 103 different race tracks and every one of them conducted racing on dirt while only nine of them, (an increase from five in 1945), conducted turf racing.  These tracks were Arlington Park, Atlantic City, Bel Air, Hamilton (Ontario, Canada), Hawthorne, Hialeah, Monmouth Park, Suffolk Downs, and Washington Park.  As incredible as it may seem, there was no turf racing in New York, California or Kentucky, these states along with Maryland, New Jersey, Florida, and Illinois to eventually become the mecca of turf racing as we know it today.

Although it was inevitable that turf racing would eventually become popular in America, one man can be given credit for kick starting its growth and that was John Shapiro, the president of Laurel Race Course in Maryland.  Laurel, which conducted its first race meet in 1911, added a turf course in 1951.  It was a bold venture, especially since those that bet on the races had little if any experience in handicapping races on the turf.  As for the horsemen themselves, many were reluctant to train horses to run on the green stuff, which at the time offered them limited opportunities to enter their horses in a race, especially a stake race.  Back then, those tracks that did run races on turf usually limited it to a single race per day and it could take several weeks before a race came up that met the conditions that would allow trainers to enter a horse that fit them.  And stake race opportunities were rare.  Of the 571 stake races offered in North America in 1950, only eight of them were on the turf (three others had been discontinued the year before) and they were usually open races for three-year-olds and up.

But Mr. Shapiro had vision and to satisfy that vision he decided to create an international race that would attract horses from Europe and Australia.  The race was the Washington D.C. International, a mile and one-half event for a purse of $50,000, the horses that would contend being by invitation only.  The first International drew horses from England (Wilwyn and Zucchero), Germany (Nierderlander), and Canada (Indian Hemp, an English bred who never stepped foot on Canadian soil but was owned by Canadian Industrialist Max Bell).  Their American opponents were Greek Ship, Ruhe, and Pilaster.

Even though the American horses were heavily favored, England’s Wilwyn was an easy winner over Ruhe as both horses came from far back to pass the early leader, Greek Ship, who was ridden by Eddie Arcaro.  In reality, America may have lost the race, but it was also a winner as a record crowd of 26,014 came to watch and they opened their wallets and bet $1,284,786 on the eight-race card, another Laurel record.

The first D.C. International was a resounding success, and the race would gain momentum throughout the 1950’s and 1960’s with a reputation for drawing some of the best turf horses in the world, both internationally as well as domestically.  It also spawned two other great turf races, both of which are still contested today, the United Nations Handicap, to be run at Atlantic City beginning in 1953, and the Man o’ War Stakes, to be run on Aqueduct’s new turf course in 1959.

And with this sudden popularity in turf racing, a new star of the turf emerged, one that you might say was hidden in plain sight.  Round Table was already a star when racing on dirt, successful against the likes of Bold Ruler, Gallant Man, Sword Dancer and Hillsdale.  In fact, 50 of his 66 starts would be on dirt tracks, but as good as he was on the traditional American surface, he was exceptional on turf, winning 14 of his 16 starts on grass with a second-place finish when he failed to give catch Clem in the 1958 U.N. Handicap, losing it by a diminishing half-length while toting 130 pounds, which was 17 more than the winner carried.  And in Round Table’s other loss, he was injured and finished last, the injury keeping him out of action for nearly four months.

As turf racing continued to evolve through the latter half of the twentieth century, we saw new stars emerge, some of which were equally as good while racing on dirt, and others that couldn’t handle the country’s dirt tracks, but would go on to be highly successful running on turf.

Following, is my top 25 list of the best male horses to run on turf in North America in the last century.  For international runners to be eligible, they must have competed at least two times on turf in North America.  Please give it a look and see what you think.

Historical Horse Racing's Top Male Turf Horses of the 20th Century

  1. Round Table
  2. Secretariat
  3. John Henry
  4. Lure
  5. Manila
  6. Dr. Fager
  7. Mongo
  8. Fort Marcy
  9. Hawaii
  10. Kotashaan
  1. Theatrical
  2. Paradise Creek
  3. Noble Dancer
  4. Mac Diarmida
  5. Star of Cozzene
  6. Bowl Game
  7. Cougar II
  8. Exceller
  9. Steinlen
  10. Kelso
  1. Run the Gantlet
  2. Flit-to
  3. Perrault
  4. Bald Eagle
  5. T.V. Lark

Profiles of Historical Horse Racing's Top Ten

#1 - Round Table

Photo: Turfotos

#2 - Secretariat

Photo: American Press

#3 - John Henry

Photo: Hollywood Park

#4 - Lure

Photo: NYRA

#5 - Manila

Photo: Keeneland Library

#6 - Dr. Fager

Photo: Pinterest

#7 - Mongo

Photo: Jim Raftery

#8 - Fort Marcy

Photo: Jim Raftery

#9 - Hawaii

Photo: Aiken Hall of Fame

#10 - Kotashaan

Photo: Terry Jones

The Next Best (11 thru 25)

NOTO: Tap on image for slide presention in LIGHT BOX DISPLAY.